Spiced Cider Bourbon

I'll never forget my first Spiced Apple Cider Bourbon cocktail. It was at a small craft cocktail bar in Vermont during peak foliage season. The bartender recommended it, describing it as "autumn in a glass," and I was skeptical – how could a simple bourbon and cider combination be that special? But one sip changed everything. The warmth of the bourbon melded perfectly with the sweet-tart cider, while the spices added layers of complexity I hadn't expected. That cinnamon stick wasn't just garnish; it infused each sip with gentle warmth. The star anise brought a subtle licorice note that made the drink feel exotic yet familiar. I asked for the recipe, and the bartender smiled and said it was almost embarrassingly simple. That's when I learned that great cocktails don't need to be complicated. This recipe captures that experience perfectly. The key is using quality ingredients – good bourbon makes a difference, as does fresh apple cider rather than apple juice. The spices should be whole and aromatic, not stale from the back of your pantry. When you make this, you're not just mixing a drink; you're creating an experience that engages all your senses.

Why I love this recipe

I love this recipe because it embodies everything wonderful about fall without being overly sweet or complicated. The bourbon provides a sophisticated base that appeals to serious cocktail enthusiasts, while the spiced cider makes it approachable and comforting for everyone. There's something magical about how the warmth of the bourbon combines with those aromatic spices – it's like wrapping yourself in a cozy blanket. I also appreciate how forgiving this recipe is. You can adjust the bourbon-to-cider ratio based on preference, add more or fewer spices, or even warm it slightly for a hot toddy variation. It's versatile enough for casual weeknight relaxation yet impressive enough for entertaining. The visual appeal matters too – that beautiful amber color, the ice glistening in the glass, the dramatic cinnamon stick and star anise garnish. It photographs beautifully, which is a bonus when friends inevitably want to share it on social media. But beyond aesthetics, this cocktail just makes people happy. I've served it at holiday parties, cozy date nights, and casual get-togethers, and it always receives rave reviews. It's become my signature fall drink, and I love how something so simple brings so much joy.

What You Need From Your Kitchen

• Bourbon whiskey: Use a quality bourbon you enjoy drinking; this forms the base spirit of the cocktail
• Apple cider: Choose fresh, unfiltered cider from a local orchard if possible for best flavor
• Cinnamon stick: Use whole sticks for garnish and gentle infusion rather than ground cinnamon
• Star anise: Adds a subtle licorice note and beautiful visual element to the drink
• Whole cloves: Provide warming spice notes without overpowering the bourbon
• Fresh apple: Slice thinly for garnish and a fresh fruit element

Let's Make These Together

Prep Your Glass with Spices

Start by filling your rocks glass with fresh ice cubes. Drop in the whole cloves and one star anise directly onto the ice. This allows the spices to start releasing their aromatic oils immediately, infusing the ice and creating a fragrant base for your cocktail. The cold temperature helps preserve the delicate spice flavors while slowly releasing them into the drink.

Pour the Bourbon Base

Measure out 2 ounces of your chosen bourbon and pour it slowly over the spiced ice. The bourbon should be at room temperature to maintain its full flavor profile. As you pour, watch how the amber liquid cascades over the ice and begins mingling with the spices. This is where the magic starts – the bourbon's caramel and vanilla notes will begin picking up the warm spice aromatics.

Add the Apple Cider

Pour 4 ounces of fresh apple cider into the glass over the bourbon and ice. The cider should be cold from the refrigerator. You'll notice the beautiful layering effect as the lighter cider initially sits atop the heavier bourbon before you stir. The natural sugars in the cider will balance the bourbon's strength while adding authentic apple flavor.

Stir and Garnish Beautifully

Using a bar spoon or long spoon, gently stir the cocktail with an up-and-down motion about 10-15 times. This properly combines the bourbon and cider while further releasing the spice flavors. Place the cinnamon stick in the glass as a stirrer, position the second star anise prominently, and add a fresh apple slice to the rim. These garnishes aren't just decorative – they continue adding flavor as you sip.

Let It Rest and Enjoy

Before taking your first sip, let the cocktail rest for about a minute or two. This brief waiting period allows all the flavors to marry together and the spices to fully bloom in the liquid. Take a moment to appreciate the aroma rising from the glass – that's the promise of the delicious sip to come. When you're ready, enjoy slowly, letting each sip warm you from the inside out.

pin it

Switch Things Up

I first made this cocktail on a crisp October evening when friends came over unexpectedly. I had bourbon in the cabinet, fresh cider from the farmer's market, and a well-stocked spice drawer – everything I needed for impromptu entertaining. As I muddled the spices and mixed the drinks, the kitchen filled with the most incredible aroma. My friends were immediately drawn to the scent before they even tasted it. What started as a quick solution became our signature fall drink. Now, every autumn, we have a tradition of making these cocktails together. I've experimented with different bourbons and spice combinations, but this version always wins. The beauty is in its simplicity – you don't need fancy equipment or hard-to-find ingredients. Just quality bourbon, good cider, and warming spices. Sometimes I'll simmer the cider with the spices first for an even deeper flavor, especially when I'm making a larger batch. Other times, I keep it quick and simple like this recipe. Both ways are delicious.

Perfect Pairings

This Spiced Apple Cider Bourbon pairs beautifully with sharp cheddar cheese and crackers, creating a lovely sweet-savory contrast. It also complements roasted nuts, especially pecans or walnuts, which echo the drink's warm, toasty notes. For a more substantial pairing, try it alongside charcuterie with prosciutto and aged cheeses. The cocktail also works wonderfully with desserts like apple pie, pumpkin bread, or cinnamon sugar donuts. If you're serving appetizers, consider pairing it with bacon-wrapped dates or baked brie with cranberry compote – the bourbon's richness stands up beautifully to these bold flavors.

pin it

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I make this cocktail without alcohol?

Yes! Simply omit the bourbon and increase the apple cider to 6 ounces. You can add a splash of sparkling water for some effervescence or a small amount of vanilla extract to add depth where the bourbon would have provided complexity.

→ What's the best type of bourbon to use?

Choose a mid-range bourbon that you enjoy drinking neat or on the rocks. Brands like Buffalo Trace, Maker's Mark, or Woodford Reserve work beautifully. Avoid very expensive bourbons as the cider and spices will mask some subtle notes, but don't use bottom-shelf bourbon either as its harshness will come through.

→ Can I make a large batch for a party?

Absolutely! Combine bourbon and cider in a pitcher using the 1:2 ratio (1 part bourbon to 2 parts cider). Add some whole spices to the pitcher and refrigerate for at least an hour. When serving, pour over ice in individual glasses and garnish each one with cinnamon sticks, star anise, and apple slices.

→ How can I make this drink warmer for cold weather?

Heat the apple cider gently on the stovetop with the cloves, star anise, and cinnamon stick for 5-10 minutes – don't let it boil. Remove from heat, strain out the spices, and pour the warm cider over bourbon in a heat-safe mug. Garnish with a fresh cinnamon stick and apple slice. It becomes more like a hot toddy this way.

→ What can I substitute if I don't have star anise?

While star anise adds a distinctive flavor, you can substitute it with a small piece of fresh ginger, additional cinnamon sticks, or a few whole allspice berries. Each will provide a different but equally delicious warming spice note to complement the bourbon and cider.

→ How long will the garnishes stay fresh in the drink?

The spices and cinnamon stick will stay fresh throughout the drink and actually improve the flavor over time. The apple slice will stay fresh for about 30 minutes before it starts to brown. If making drinks ahead, add the apple slice just before serving for the best visual presentation.

Conclusion

This Spiced Apple Cider Bourbon Cocktail is the epitome of autumn in a glass. The combination of smooth bourbon with warming spices and sweet apple cider creates a drink that's both sophisticated and comforting. Whether you're hosting a fall gathering or simply unwinding after a long day, this cocktail delivers every time. The aromatic spices not only enhance the flavor but also fill your space with that irresistible fall fragrance. It's proof that simple ingredients, when combined thoughtfully, can create something truly special.