Chicken Salad Sandwich

I first discovered the magic of a really good chicken salad sandwich during a road trip through New England, where every small-town deli seemed to have their own special version. What struck me was how such simple ingredients – chicken, mayo, celery, and good bread – could create something so incredibly satisfying. When I got home, I was determined to recreate that experience, and after several attempts, I landed on this version using sourdough bread, which adds that perfect tangy complement to the creamy filling. The key is in the balance: you want enough mayo to bind everything together without making it soggy, plenty of crisp vegetables for texture, and chicken that's tender but not mushy. I learned that letting the chicken salad chill for at least 30 minutes before assembling allows all those flavors to meld together beautifully. The lettuce and tomato aren't just garnishes – they're essential components that add freshness and prevent the sandwich from being too heavy. What makes this recipe special is that it respects each ingredient's role while creating something greater than the sum of its parts.

Why I love this recipe

I love this recipe because it's the perfect example of how simple food done right can be absolutely extraordinary. There's something deeply satisfying about making a sandwich that looks like it came from a gourmet deli but required minimal cooking skills and basic ingredients you probably already have. It's incredibly practical – you can use leftover chicken, rotisserie chicken, or even cook chicken specifically for this purpose, and the chicken salad keeps well in the fridge for several days, making it perfect for meal prep. What really wins me over is the texture combination: the crispy, tangy sourdough against the creamy chicken salad, the crunch of celery and the bite of red onion, all balanced by fresh lettuce and juicy tomatoes. It's a sandwich that works for so many occasions – a quick weekday lunch, a weekend picnic, a light dinner, or even an elegant brunch option when you cut them into smaller portions. Plus, it's endlessly customizable based on what you have available or your personal preferences, yet the basic formula always delivers that same comforting, delicious result.

What You Need From Your Kitchen

• Cooked chicken breast: Shred into bite-sized pieces for the salad base
• Mayonnaise: Mix with chicken to create the creamy binding sauce
• Celery: Dice finely and add for crunchy texture and fresh flavor
• Red onion: Dice small and fold in for a sharp, tangy bite
• Sourdough bread: Toast until golden and use as the sandwich base
• Lettuce: Layer fresh leaves for crisp texture and color
• Tomatoes: Slice thick and add for juicy freshness

Let's Make These Together

Cook and shred chicken

Start by cooking your chicken breasts until they reach an internal temperature of 165°F, ensuring they're fully cooked but still juicy. Let them cool completely before shredding – this prevents the mayo from separating when you mix everything together. Use two forks to pull the chicken apart into bite-sized shreds, or use your hands for more control over the texture.

Mix creamy chicken salad

In your large mixing bowl, combine the shredded chicken with mayonnaise, making sure every piece gets coated in that creamy goodness. Fold in your diced celery for crunch and red onion for a bit of sharpness. Season generously with salt and pepper, tasting as you go to get the seasoning just right. The key here is balance – you want it creamy but not drowning in mayo, flavorful but not overwhelming.

Toast sourdough perfectly

Heat your skillet to medium and place your sourdough slices down to toast. Watch them carefully – you want that beautiful golden-brown color and crispy texture without burning. The toast should be sturdy enough to hold all that delicious chicken salad without getting soggy. If you're feeling fancy, brush the bread with a little butter before toasting for extra richness.

Layer fresh vegetables

Start with crisp lettuce leaves as your base – they act as a barrier between the bread and the moist chicken salad. Wash and thoroughly dry your lettuce to avoid any excess water. Slice your tomatoes into thick, even rounds, and if they're particularly juicy, you can gently squeeze out some seeds to keep things from getting too wet.

Assemble and serve

Now comes the fun part! Lay your toasted bread out, add that lettuce barrier, then pile on a generous amount of chicken salad. Top with your tomato slices and the second piece of toast. Press down gently but firmly to help everything stick together. Cut diagonally for that classic sandwich shop look, and serve immediately while the bread is still crispy and warm.

pin it

Switch Things Up

I remember the first time I made this sandwich for a weekend lunch gathering with friends. I had leftover rotisserie chicken from dinner the night before and thought, why not turn it into something special? I shredded that chicken, mixed it with all the fresh ingredients I had in the fridge, and toasted some artisan sourdough I'd picked up from the local bakery. When I assembled those sandwiches and cut them in half, revealing all those gorgeous layers, everyone gathered around the kitchen island. The first bite was met with silence – the good kind – followed by enthusiastic compliments. My friend Sarah asked for the recipe three times before she left! What really makes this special is using quality sourdough bread; that tangy flavor and chewy texture elevates the entire sandwich. Now it's become my signature dish for casual get-togethers, and I always make extra chicken salad because people inevitably ask for seconds.

Perfect Pairings

This Sourdough Chicken Salad Sandwich pairs beautifully with crispy pretzel sticks or potato chips for that satisfying crunch alongside each bite. For a lighter option, serve it with a fresh garden salad dressed with a light vinaigrette, or try classic coleslaw for a traditional deli-style meal. A bowl of tomato soup makes this combination extra comforting on cooler days. For beverages, iced tea – whether sweetened or unsweetened – complements the creamy chicken salad perfectly, or try fresh lemonade for a bright, refreshing contrast. If you're serving this for a gathering, add pickle spears and vegetable sticks with ranch dip to round out the plate.

pin it

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I make this chicken salad ahead of time?

Absolutely! The chicken salad mixture actually tastes better when made ahead because it gives the flavors time to meld together. You can prepare it up to 2 days in advance and store it in an airtight container in the refrigerator. Just wait to toast the bread and assemble the sandwiches until you're ready to eat to keep everything fresh and crispy.

→ What can I use instead of mayonnaise?

If you're not a fan of mayo or want a lighter option, you can substitute with Greek yogurt, sour cream, or a combination of both. Avocado also makes a great creamy base. Keep in mind that these substitutions will slightly change the flavor profile, but they're all delicious alternatives that still give you that creamy texture.

→ Can I use a different type of bread?

Definitely! While sourdough adds wonderful tangy flavor and sturdy texture, you can use any bread you prefer. Whole wheat, multigrain, ciabatta, croissants, or even lettuce wraps for a low-carb option all work well. Just make sure whatever bread you choose is sturdy enough to hold the filling without getting soggy.

→ How do I keep the sandwich from getting soggy?

The key is creating barriers and timing. Always place lettuce leaves directly on the toasted bread before adding the chicken salad – this creates a protective layer. Make sure your lettuce and tomatoes are thoroughly dried. Toast your bread well so it's crispy and more resistant to moisture. Most importantly, assemble the sandwich right before eating rather than making it hours in advance.

→ What other ingredients can I add to the chicken salad?

This recipe is incredibly versatile! Popular additions include diced apples or grapes for sweetness, chopped pecans or walnuts for extra crunch, dried cranberries for a tart element, fresh herbs like dill or tarragon, a squeeze of lemon juice for brightness, or even a touch of curry powder for an Indian-inspired twist. Start with the base recipe and customize it to your taste preferences.

→ How long will the assembled sandwich stay fresh?

For best quality, eat the assembled sandwich within 2-3 hours of making it. If you need to pack it for lunch, keep the components separate and assemble right before eating. The chicken salad itself will keep in the refrigerator for 3-4 days, so you can prep it in advance and make fresh sandwiches throughout the week.

Conclusion

This Sourdough Chicken Salad Sandwich is the ultimate comfort food that brings together simple, quality ingredients in perfect harmony. The combination of creamy chicken salad with crunchy vegetables and toasted sourdough creates a satisfying meal that works for lunch, dinner, or even a picnic. It's incredibly versatile – you can customize the vegetables, adjust the creaminess, or add your favorite seasonings. Whether you're meal prepping for the week or making a quick lunch, this sandwich delivers every single time with minimal effort and maximum flavor.